Not a lot of new info in this report on the TBTF banks’ settlement discussions for manipulating foreign exchange rates, or forex. There are a few tidbits at the inside-baseball level that are interesting. If you’ve been reading my posts on banking fiascos, you will appreciate this info.
2/13 – Bloomberg Business – U.S. is Seeking Billions from Global Banks in Currency Manipulation Settlement –
DoJ is looking for a simultaneous settlement with all the banks so none of them are singled out.
Total dollar amount on the table is reportedly $4B with starting point for each bank about $1B, give or take.
Here’s what the really deep-inside-baseball lineup is looking like:
- Barclays – settlement & guilty plea
- Citigroup- settlement & guilty plea
- JPMorgan- settlement & guilty plea
- RBS- settlement & guilty plea
- UBS – smaller settlement than others but no guilty plea since they participated early
HSBC isn’t on the list. Won’t backtrack to recall why at the moment.
Those five plus HSBC already agreed to pay $4.3B to a variety of regulators.
Article hints, like previous reports, that there may be individual prosecutions.
Increases in reserves for legal settlements in the 4th quarter, per the article:
- $1.1B – Barclays
- $2.9B – Citigroup
- $1.1B – JPMorgan
- $1.7B – RBS
- $0.2B – UBS
What about DFS? What’s the total settlement tab gonna’ be?
Most remarkable thing in the article is no mention anywhere of what NY Department of Financial Services may want to see in a settlement. I’ll make a completely wild guess they will be looking for dollars in the same range as DoJ, or maybe higher.
My guess from my tiny little desk in my tiny little corner of the audit world of total fines for manipulating forex: $4.4B already paid, plus $4B to DoJ, plus another $2B to $5B to NYDFS, plus another $2B from HSBC, add a +/-$1B factor, for a range of $11B to $16B with point estimate of $13B.
So here’s a question for C-suite managers: how much would effective internal controls of trading desks have cost? Less than a couple of billion per bank?
Some of my previous posts:
- 2/13/15 – Maybe some criminal prosecutions this time around from HSBC and forex investigations
- 1/23/15 – More good stuff on banking fiascos
- 11/13/14 – A few updates on the Forex settlement
- 11/12/14 – Settlements for Forex manipulation announced. We will need to wait for all settlements to learn if this is only a cost of doing business
- 10/31/14 – Update on Forex manipulation. Also, another thought why the banking fiascos won’t be ending anytime soon
- 9/15/14 – Next banking fiasco? Manipulating foreign exchange rates?